AHIA election of 1 Sept 2018 a sham

By Ashok Kumar

The Australian Hindi Indian Association (AHIA) held its Annual General Meeting (AGM) on Saturday, 1 September, 2018 where it elected new office bearers for the next four years.  Amid the confusion , voting was conducted and a new AHIA team was elected that included, five women members, a first in an Indian association.

The new team members are: Mr. Yash Bhasin (President), Mr. Rajendra Channa (Vice-President), Mr. Kali Das Gupta (Secretary), Mr. Vipen Dogra (Treasurer). The Executive Members (All Women) : Ms. Sushma Ahluwalia, Ms. Sudha Ramdev, Ms. Sarita Sachdev, Ms. Meeta Sharma, Ms. Preeti Thadani. The winning team (Group B) polled 99 votes as against 49 for Group A. But, according to the Returning officer (R. O), Mr. Jagdish Dua, quoting attendance sheet, announced a total of 189 members attended. However, he announced that overall 212 people voted, a discrepancy of 23 votes.

While there was confusion about the conduct of voting and some felt that a correct procedure was not followed, Mr. Sukhdev Jaswal of the other camp (Group A) protested but his pleas were drowned in the melee.

The IST correspondent observed Mr. Dua announcing that the total votes counted was 212 while 189 members were present according to the attendance sheets. The Group A did not accept the result on this basis and asked the voting to be declared null and void. The ballot papers were not signed by the Returning Officer, Mr.Jagdish Dua, either.
The IST also observed that the unsigned ballot papers were just distributed instead of being given to members at the time of entry when the attendance was being marked. There seemed to be  no control over who was being handed the ballot paper and how many.
Mr Dua put it to the audience whether they would like the voting to be null and void and another date be fixed for the vote.  This procedure, according to the Fair Trading rules, is illegal. The supporters of Group B were more vocal and said no to that. Mr Dua based on hand counts declared the result in favour of Group B.

This correspondent also observed that to avoid votes becoming invalid, the R.O. should have demonstrated how to vote procedure as most members were very old or infirm. In its absence members voted as per their understanding. The invalid votes of 68 people (about 1/3 of the total) are far too many.

If the nominations were asked for individual positions and proposers and seconders were also individuals, as was the case for AHIA elections, then how come election was conducted between Group A and Group B? There is no such group election in AHIA constitution, observed many. AHIA constitution says it follows model constitution from Department of NSW Fair Trading, which talks about individual elections of individual positions, not group elections.

The election appeared a one-sided match. The IST sent a questionnaire to Mr. Dua through an email seeking clarifications and set a deadline till 7 Sept 2018 5.00 pm but instead of setting the matter straight for the members, he ignored the email.

Hence, it will be pertinent to ask the R.O. to set the matter straight by following the NSW Fair Trading rules and AHIA Constitution.

Meanwhile, after publication of the news item, Mr. Dua responded to the emails thus: Mr. Dua’s email is copied and pasted.

Dear Mr Ashok Kumar
This is in response to your e-mails and the “Opinion” piece in the Indian Sub-continent Times.
AHIA Executive resolved to appoint me to chair the AGM and to be the Returning Officer for the AHIA elections.
AHIA Elections were conducted in the fair, free and relatively orderly manner.
The election process did not contravene AHIA Constitution in any way.
The declared results of the elections represented the will of the members present at the AGM.
Best regards.
Jagdish Dua




Share this :

About Ashok Kumar

Ashok Kumar is an accomplished journalist with over 38 years of experience in the profession in various capacities. He was a sub-editor in Patriot and later Chief Sub-editor in The Hindustan Times, New Delhi. He has several published articles and reports in Patriot and HT. Published reports in The Blacktown Sun in Sydney. He had also been a tutor in journalism in the University of Western Sydney. He is currently Editor at The Indian Sub-continent Times, Sydney.

View all posts by Ashok Kumar →

Leave a Reply